I really would like to on the Mushroom Island could be brown mooshrooms too, not only red ones and the brown ones be a bit more rarely. But important they stay one kind, so from the same original red mooshroom spawn egg, the brown mooshroom variation too. They could breed (when we feed them with wheat) to make baby mooshrooms, which ones become of course be randomly red, or brown baby mooshroom. On the brown mooshrooms' head and back of course be the original little brown mushrooms. If we shear the brown mooshrooms, they give us brown mushrooms and of course if we shear the red mooshrooms, they give us red mushrooms.
I tell exist a Brown mooshrooms mod already, but in that the brown mooshroom is in a new spawn egg and they can't mate with red ones, just brown with brown and red with red, what is so strange. That's why i ask this mod, where the brown mooshrooms are from the same spawn egg and can breed with red mooshrooms too. The mod be for Minecraft 1.12.2.
Here is an own modified good brown mooshroom texture PNG by me, please apply this in the mod:
And a bonus, but not should, just could be interesting: the red and brown mooshrooms could spawn in Roofed Forest too, but more rarely, not common like on Mushroom Island (because there are big mushrooms too). And if possible to make mod support, then please make if we use the Biomes O Plenty mod, then in the Mystic Grove biome rarely spawn only red mooshrooms (there are few big red mushrooms) and in the Bog biome spawn only brown mooshrooms (there are big brown mushrooms). But in Roofed Forest more important and the other things! It could be a great mod and some players maybe would like it.
The mod's name don't be Brown mooshrooms, because as i said, it's exist already, but not so good, i said why. So i think the mod's name be Mooshrooms, or Mooshroom Bonus, or Mooshroom Plus.
Please somebody seriously make it, i am really waiting for it!
If somebody make it and upload to the Minecraft CurseForge, i really thanks!
So like a situation similar to Horses and Donkeys making a Mule but with Mooshrooms, you'd be able to shear both red and brown mushrooms or get both when defeating them maybe.
And the use for the Roofed Forest makes sense and I think that's a good idea. I'd like to see a mod like that.
You could request it to the 1.14 Fabric modding team if you want and see what they think (as Brown Mushrooms are a 1.14 thing after all), you can respond to them on their Discord here: https://discord.gg/v6v4pMv
Lol, i don't understand how came here the horses, donekeys and mules, so strange example. Mushroom horses not exist. Yes, i know from 1.14 exist originally the brown mooshrooms in Minecraft. But i don't play with 1.14 and i don't like we can get brown mooshrooms only, if the thunder is hit the mooshrooms. I don't have Discord, i won't register only because of that. I think give me the Fabric boss's profile from the Minecraft CurseForge website, i am there usually and then i can PM him. Do you think they make mods for 1.12.2, if i ask them and id they agree with it? Since i found this:
By Horses, Donkeys and Mules, I meant a mixed breed, which Mules are a mix of Donkeys and Horses. I thought that was clear enough and that it seemed like the closest to what you were meaning/a thing that exists in the game already/wouldn't be confusing compared to pulling a random non-existent similarity out of my hat.
A 1.12.2 mod could exist since some developers that make current updates features into mods for past versions. I'd say ask some of them and see if they are up for the challenge. I don't remember the mods names right now but there is a few out there if I remember correctly.
If you don't want to register with Discord that's perfectly fine and I can respect that. I only use it due to covering Fabric mods heavily on Youtube mostly (besides helping a datapack dev), I don't use it for much else really and wouldn't even bother with it since I don't really need it.
Asie is the creator of Fabric yes, they are just focusing on Fabric to give devs options, but there is many devs porting to Fabric that support 1.12.2 and 1.13.2 Forge/Rift or 1.14 Fabric but it depends on the developers.
I'll pass the message on to them once I drop by again today and see what they think but otherwise if it's for 1.12.2 your best to ask one of the devs that does newer update features for past versions.
After just looking for a Brown Mooshroom mod or update features that are backported before ending off this comment, I found this Brown Mooshroom mod already, try asking them I'd say and they might add the feature your looking for. I already put up my comment there just encase but if you want to expand on your thoughts besides me just linking this thread and a bit of brief explanation then go for it:
Hmm, i see. But the brown mooshroom is not a crossbreed like the mule from horse and donkey. Brown mooshroom is just another mooshroom, nothing more.
I wrote down upper i know about that Brown mooshrooms mod, i quote it back:
"I tell exist a Brown mooshrooms mod already, but in that the brown mooshroom is in a new spawn egg and they can't mate with red ones, just brown with brown and red with red, what is so strange."
I thought then you think i asked that mod's creator is he could make the brown mooshroom, so yes, i asked him before, just other way, not like that. So i asked him there now about the same spawn egg. I saw he answered you already there.
Do you mean you write to Asie in PM on CurseForge about it? If yes, thank you. Then link him that forum topic, ask him he read it carefully and write me in PM on CurseForge what he think, will he, or one of them, can he make it, or one of them with the same spawn egg, from the red mooshroom spawn egg, from that spawn the brown mooshroom too, then they can be breed with each other (red with brown mooshroom too). That's the most important part of the mod.
Since i added a texture for the brown mooshroom upper in the 1st comment, which be added to the mod.
So instead of a Horse/Donkey situation it's more like a rare breed or a sheep wool like thing maybe where you get the combination of what their wool is like (not sure if that's a thing but it is or something like that could be possible then ok I guess, I don't know how to end this part).
I did miss you saying you knew about the mod, my bad, a lot to read, thinking too much about what to say, not a lot I processed there, my own fault, apologies.
I'd not be PMing Asie, I'd be forwarding the idea to the dev team and seeing if the developers are interested to pick it up. I'll link the thread here over there. Just did now.
Yes, rare breed, but the brown mooshroom is not a rare mixed animal like the mule, so not the same.
Ok, so you didn't read it 1st time, but you did it now already. It's ok.
Oh ok, so then you wrote to the team about it and you linked that forum about that mod request. Thank you. I hope they will read it carefully. They could write me in PM on Minecraft CurseForge, mainly if they make this mod as i asked. Will they answer to you, or to me about it? If yes, i would like to know it somehow here, or on Minecraft CurseForge in PM from them.
Thank you, but the screenshot is not about it what i sent you in PM. Just a resource pack, what i did, not really for this topic.
Since somebody added to his mod as an extra this brown mooshrooms thing well. They just not spawn in Roofed Forest and in Bog, in Mystic Grove either. Maybe he misunderstood me, or that was easier to him to add one his mods as an extra, i don't know his reason. He is AstroTibs and he added it to his Not Enough Cats mod, he wrote it in the changelog:
As i saw, he replaced the vanilla mooshrooms and in that he made the 2 kind of mooshrooms and that's how they both from the same vanilla red mooshroom spawn egg. I tested it, it's working well (both variation mooshrooms spawn and if we shear the brown, she drop brown mushrooms, the red drop red ones like originally), but i asked him he make it as a new mod, it could be better and i asked him the Roofed Forest thing too. I don't know will he make it as a new mod and the spawn in other biomes too, what i asked. I think his mod's code can be a good template about the brown mooshrooms for who maybe make this mod as a new mod with one of the suggested names and with other biomes spawning, which ones i asked here in my 1st comment. So i don't know how it will end yet, we will see it.
He don't want to add for it they spawn in Roofed Forest too and he wanted to add it only for the Not Enough Cats mod. I accepted it, better than nothing. But it could be good, if the mooshrroms could spawn in Roofed Forest toom just a bit rarely than on Mushroom Island. And he added it to the Not Enough Cats mod's older versions too, like for 1.7.10 and few other ones. Who interested it more, just search for the Not Enough Cats mod on the Minecraft CurseForge. You can read about it in the changelog. Of course if you don't interested the cats, you can turen them off and you can use the brown mooshrooms only with the red ones together.